Following the success ofThe Lord of the Ringstrilogy, Hollywood planned to adaptJ. R. R. Tolkien’s other major fantasy work,The Hobbit. After a lengthy round of behind-the-scenes legal drama, which saw the departure of the original director,Guillermo del Toro,Sir Peter Jacksonreturned to the director’s seat, turning the book into a new trilogy. Unfortunately, this new trio of moviesfailed to capture the majesty of the bookor theLord of the Ringsseries due to a bloated runtime, overuse of CGI, and mediocre character writing.
Many fans were quick to point out that, despiteThe Hobbitbeing the shortest of Tolkien’s works, it was made into three very long films. Amazingly,even with all of this runtime, many storylines are left unresolved. When the extended edition came out, some received proper conclusions at the cost of forcing audiences to spend more money on content that should have been in the original release. However,other storylines weren’t so lucky, remaining unresolvedwith no hope of ever seeing them fulfilled.
10The Troll Gold
Some Extra Gold Never Recovered
Early in the quest, Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman) and the dwarves are saved by the wizard Gandalf (Sir Ian McKellen) from a trio of hungry trolls. Delving into the troll’s cave, they discover many treasures, including the swords Orcrist, Glamdring, and Sting, which Thorin (Richard Armitage), Gandalf, and Bilbo take, respectively. The other dwarves also find a small pile of wealth, which they bury for later recovery.
In the book, Bilbo recovers the troll gold on his way home, but since he already has more than enough treasure, he hands it to Gandalf, who says he will put the gold to good use. It’s a small moment, but poignant for highlighting one ofAn Unexpected Journey’s main themesregarding sharing wealth rather than hoarding it. The films omit this scene and simply forget about the gold, which makes one wonder why they even showed the dwarves burying the gold in the first place.
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
9Bilbo’s Acorn
A Last Minute Detail With No Resolution
While staying at the house of the skinchanger, Beorn (Mikael Persbrandt), Bilbo takes an acorn offscreen. He shows it to Thorin, who believes Bilbo might have had his missing heirloom, the Arkenstone, and tells him that he intends to plant it back home to remind him of the adventure. As Thorin lies dying afterthe eclectic Battle of the Five Armies, he tells Bilbo to plant his tree and watch it grow.
The acorn is a strange addition toThe Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armiessince the audience never sees Bilbo pick it up.It’s meant to visualize Bilbo’s love for the simple pleasures in life instead of treasure, but since there is no scene of Bilbo planting it, it comes across as a bit hollow. There isa deleted sceneof Bilbo planting the acorn to inspire Bard (Luke Evans) to keep fighting for the promise of a better tomorrow, but it wasn’t even restored in the extended edition.
8Radagast and Mirkwood
Does His Forest Get Healed Or Not?
One of the five wizards tasked with helping the people of Middle Earth combat the forces of evil,Radagast the Brown(Sylvester McCoy) prefers to spend his time among nature, tending to the birds and beasts of the Greenwood. One day, a mysterious corruption known as Mirkwood spreads through the woods, killing animals and heralding giant spiders. Following them, Radagast discovers a Necromancer setup in the fortress of Dol Guldur, who is revealed to be Sauron (Benedict Cumberbatch).
Radagast is last seen flying atop the backs of the eagles as they join the Battle of the Five Armies,but there is no indication if he survives or not. There is also no explanation if the sickness on Mirkwood, or the giant spiders, vanished following Sauron’s banishment by the White Council. Given that the corruption of the forest is also linked to the Mirkwood Elves under King Thranduil (Lee Pace), and Radagast’s investigation of the corruption is what revealed Sauron,it’s baffling that they’re all but abandoned.
A Fan Favourite Side-Character Who Does Nothing
On the run from the pale orc, Azog the Deflier (Manu Bennett), Gandalf leads Bilbo and the dwarves to the house of Beorn, the skin-changer. Able to shift between man and bear, Beorn has more than enough reasons to hate the orcs since his people were hunted or captured for sport. This hatred compels Beorn to help the dwarves, whom he also doesn’t like since they don’t care as much for the natural world as they do gold.
Beorn is last seen leaping into the orc army from the back of an eagle, but even in the extended edition, all he does is toss orcs around. It was farfetched to believe that he would get to kill either Azog or his son, Bolg (Lawrence MakoareandJohn Tui), for revenge against his people like in the book, but the rest of his epilogue is sadly removed. He was supposed to accompany Bilbo and Gandalf part of the way back west and become more sociable, leading to an era of security and prosperity in the lands surrounding his home. Instead, Beorn is sort of just there, andhis story receives no proper conclusion.
The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug
An Unnecessary Love Triangle That Overstayed Its Welcome
InThe Hobbitmovies,the writers created Tauriel(Evangeline Lilly), a Sylvan elf who serves as Thranduil’s captain of the guard and has a friendship with his son, Legolas (Orlando Bloom), who is attracted to her. Unfortunately for him, she falls for Thorin’s nephew, Kili (Aidan Turner), to the point where she is willing to defy her king’s commands if it means keeping him safe. Ultimately, she does little to help the primary characters, is banished from Mirkwood for defying Thruaduil, and can only watch as a Bolg kills Kili in front of her.
One would think that Tauriel would be the one to avenge Kili by killing Bolg, or at least try to, but the writers gave this task to Legolas instead,leaving Tauriel’s story in an awkward position. The last time she appears is when mourning Kili’s loss while Thranduil acknowledges their love as real.What she does afterward, be it wandering the world or returning home if Thranduil lifts her banishment,is anyone’s guess, which is baffling given how much screentime she received.
Helps Defend Erebor, But His Coronation is Behind a Paywall
The lord of the Iron Hills and cousin to Thorin, Dain Ironfoot (Billy Connolly), comes to Thorin’s aid with an army of dwarves to defend Erebor from the men of Laketown and the elves of Mirkwood, who have come for a share of the treasure. Their battle is interrupted by a massive army of orcs led by Azog. Dain wastes no time ordering his dwarves to face the new threat and is joined by the men and elves in fighting for their mutual survival.
With Thorin and both of his nephews slain in the battle, Dain is crowned the new King Under the Mountain, but audiences need to buy the extended edition to see this. This is another baffling decision since reclaiming Erebor was one of the primary motivations for the whole trilogy, sonot confirming who would rule it when the royal line ended feels shortsighted. Even worse is that neither version of the film reveals just how generous Dain was as a leader and ally, leaving his film version asa very memorable characterbut with no indication of what kind of king he would be.
4Bard and Dale
Does the Dragonslayer Get His Dues?
When the company’sactions awaken the wrath of the dragon Smaug (Benedict Cumberbatch), he flies to Laketown to exact revenge on the men who live there for aiding the dwarves. It falls to Bard, the descendant of Girion, Lord of Dale, to kill the dragon and rally the survivors to brace for the coming winter. He joins forces with Thranduil to collect a share of the treasure, which proves to be difficult once Thorin falls under dragon sickness.
One would think that since Bard was the one to kill the trilogy’s primary antagonist, his story would be a top priority and worthy of a proper conclusion. Alas,fans never know if he gets the promised treasure or if it was used to rebuild Laketown, Dale, or both. The most that Bard gets is in the extended edition, where he and the rest of the Laketown survivors mourn Thorin’s death. This act, although noble, feels out of place, given how everything that happened to them was Thorin’s fault.
3White Gems of Lasgalen
What Happened to The Gems That Almost Started a War?
During the opening flashback detailing the history of Erebor, Thranduil commissions the dwarves of Erebor to fashion the White Gems of Lasgalen into a necklace. However, the gems are withheld from him due to improper payment and lost when Smaug claims the mountain. Decades later, Thranduil still covets the gems and is willing to go to war for their retrieval.
Neitherthe theatrical nor the extended edition ofThe Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armiesconfirms if Thranduil gets the gems. What’s more, neither version tells audiences that Thranduil wants them so badly because they belonged to his dead wife: this information comes from a deleted scene. Again, these gems serve as the primary driving force of one of the trilogy’s main players, so conveying their resolution and importance to the character should be nothing less than mandatory.
The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies
2Alfrid Lickspittle
Unfunny Comic Relief Who Almost Gets Off Scott Free
To contribute to the expanded Lake Town storyline,The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug’s writers created Alfrid Lickspittle (Ryan Gage). He is a toady to the Master of Laketown (Steven Fry), who helps him hoard the town’s wealth, acting as Prince John and the Sherrif of Nottingham to Bard’s expanded Robin Hood-esk role. Following the Master’s death at the beginning of TheBattle of The Five Armies,Alfrid attaches himself to Bard and becomes an unfunny and aggravating source of comic relief. He spends the movie being unhelpful, rude, and lazy before running off dressed as a woman with a bra full of gold.
Alfrid might be the worst addition to the moviesbecause the screen time he leeches could have gone to any of the many unresolved plotlines. At the very least, he gets killed off in the extended edition, but it’s so over the top with its symbolism that it’s hard to take seriously. The biggest issue with Alfrid’s story is that, regardless of which version fans watch, he’s completely superfluous. The story has enough examples of the corrupting power of greed, and his halfhearted attempts to tempt Bard lead to nothing, making his whole story pointless.
1The Arkenstone
The McGuffin That Started It All Is All But Forgotten
Called the King’s Jewel, the Arkenstone lay in the heart of Erebor and became the family heirloom of the Kings Under the Mountain. Unfortunately, it was lost when Smaug took Erebor; without it, the dwarven people became scattered and leaderless. As such, Gandalf convinces Thorin to go on a quest to retrieve the Arkenstone so he can unite his people and retake Erebor with an army.
The Arkenstone is the single most important object in the story, kickstarting the entire plot. This crucial quality makes it all the more infuriating when, in the theatrical cut of the films, the last time it is seen or mentioned is when Bard puts it away during negotiations. The extended editions do include itduring Thorin Oakenshield’s funeral, but even then, its importance is nowhere near what it’s supposed to be. It wouldn’t be a stretch to say that Bard could have decided to use the Arkenstone as a paperweight, and it wouldn’t have made much of a difference.
