Editor’s note: The below contains spoilers for Dune: Prophecy.
More than anything,Dune: Prophecyis an origin story for the modern incarnation of theDunefranchise. Based on the 2012 prequel novelSisterhood of DunebyBrian HerbertandKevin J. Anderson, theMaxseries has already given us a glimpse atthe early days of Houses Corrino, Atreides, and Harkonnen,all three of which are far from possessing the intimidating influence they later wield duringDenis Villeneuve’s recent films. On top of this, showrunnerAlison Schapker’s series has also revealed the surprising origin behinda key power wielded by the Bene Gesserit, and this week’s episode takes things one step further byredefining one of the most recognizable phrases in the franchise’s lore.
Originally included in the first ofFrank Herbert’sDunenovels, even people who don’t follow the sci-fi behemoth have probably heard the iconic line “Fear is the mind-killer.” One of the first lines inthe Bene Gesserit’s Litany Against Fear in the series, the phrase appears everywhere in connection with traditionalDunelore, includingDavid Lynch’s 1984 adaptationof the novel and one of the first scenes of Villeneuve’s remake. As such, it only makes sense thatDune: Prophecywould use its ancient focus to explore the origins of the iconic sayingin its most recent episode, thoughthe series' explanation of Herbert’s line is still darkerthan most people probably would have guessed.
What Does “Fear Is the Mind-Killer” Mean in the Dune Universe?
In order to understand howDune: Prophecyis redefining the franchise’s classic phrase, it is first important to reiterate how “Fear is the mind-killer” typically operates within Herbert’s canon. Taken at face value,the line refers to the debilitating effects of terror on an individual’s ability to thinkclearly, underscoring how fear erases humanity’s ability to function and clouds reason with paranoia and suspicion. Within the context of the full Litany Against Fear,the iconicDunephrase also meansa person must endure their fear in order to let it go, with the ultimate goal being for an individual to embrace their “inner eye” until they are self-actualized. The phrase has resonated with countlesspeople struggling with anxiety and self-doubtsinceDunewas released, which is why it should come as no surprise that the line continuesto be a fan-favorite associated with the franchise.
Aside from the line’s inspirational qualities, however, “Fear is the mind-killer” and its place in the Litany Against Fear alsocontextualize the greater power struggle that is constantly unfolding withinDune’s main story.The Litany’s goal, which is the ascension of an individual above their fears for the purpose of self-advancement, illustratesthe Bene Gesserit’s greater missionin Herbert’s universe — the creation of the Kwisatz Haderach, or the Bene Gesserit’s perfect intergalactic ruler.Dune: Prophecyhas already explained the early stages of the Sisterhood’s plan to achieve this end, and the Bene Gesserit’s famous incantation strengthens their resolve to pursue their idealized monarch. In Lynch and Villeneuve’s adaptations, we see both Paul (Kyle MacLachlan) and his mother (Rebecca Ferguson) muttering the phrase after Paul puts his hand inthe Reverend Mother’s pain box, underscoring howthe Litany’s most infamous line lends the Bene Gesserit strengthduring even the most agonizing times.
‘Dune: Prophecy’s Latest Episode Completely Redefines Frank Herbert’s Classic Phrase
This week’s episode ofDune: Prophecysuggests this line may actually be as much a warning as it is an inspirational quote, however. After almost allthe Sisterhood’s trainees succumb to nightmareson Wallach IX, Tula (Olivia Williams) attempts to understand her sisters’ visions by guiding them througha drawing exercise meant to help them recreate and understand their shared trauma, but it doesn’t take long for this effort to quickly backfire. After the trainees slip out of Tula’s control and begin feverishly scribbling visions of the Reckoning Mother Raquella (Cathy Tyson) hinted at in Episode 1, Tula finds her own reasons for fear while reviewing the sketches with Sister Avila (Barbara Marten). Identifying the same looming, godlike figure in each of the trainees' final drawings,Tula observes that the being instills a paralyzing terror in whomever it contacts, even going so far as to theorize that this terror can kill those who succumb to it.
While still a theory, this suggestion is supported by plenty of evidence in the series so far, most notably by the similar nightmare Kasha suffered prior to being burned alive by Desmond Hart’s (Travis Fimmel) power from across the universe. Had the fear induced by this dream given Hart a gateway to scorch his rival for the Emperor’s (Mark Strong) ear, it would explainthe self-righteous soldier’s impossible reach, butthis development also completely redefines everything we know aboutDune’s most famous phrase. Rather than simply being a personal mantra meant to hone the mindset of the Bene Gesserit and eventual Kwisatz Haderach,Dune: Prophecyis arguing that “Fear is the mind-killer"also possesses a literal connotation in its universe. Those who cannot endure the terror ofDesmond Hart’s mysterious powerare doomed to burn, raising the stakes for a young Sisterhood that seems woefully unprepared to face this new, elusive foe.
‘Dune: Prophecy’ Just Revealed Another Piece of Deep-Cut Lore From Frank Herbert’s Universe
And it’s all thanks to Sister Theodosia.
‘Dune Prophecy’s Revelation Brings Us One Step Closer to the Bene Gesserit’s Origins
On one hand,Dune: Prophecy’s update to Herbert’s line can’t help but feel just a little anticlimactic, grounding the empowering phrase in a more literal interpretation, but the series’ added context is alsoperfect for establishing the full scope ofthe Bene Gesserit’s origins. While Schapker’s series has thus far illustrated the material aspects of the Sisterhood’s rise to prominence, detailing how Valya Harkonnen (Emily Watson) has expanded the order’s numbers and influence with the Great Houses, Episode 4’s focus on the very real threat of fear within the Bene Gesserit’s rankssets up the establishment of the order’s most classic phrase without saying it. Tula’s suspicions open the door for the Sisterhood to develop their Litany Against Fear in response to the threat posed by Desmond Hart, allowingDune: Prophecyto further realize the core beliefs of the Bene Gesserit’s harsh beginnings.
Unfortunately,Dune: ProphecyEpisode 4 also confirms thatthe Bene Gesserit of this time periodare in no condition to combat the rising tide of fear in the Imperium. Aside from the younger sisters' nightmares, Tula herself is haunted by her own vision of murdering Sister Emeline (Aoife Hinds) at the end of Episode 4, and the Great Houses themselves are terrorized into falling in lineat Episode 4’s Landsraad. From a narrative standpoint, however, these shortcomings are equally exciting, asthey set the Bene Gesserit on the path to conquering their fearsand developing the most popular mantra inDune. Therefore, Episode 4’s update to the franchise’s iconic line not only raises the stakes for the well-being ofDune: Prophecy’s characters, but it also provides the Bene Gesserit withthe perfect enemy to help them realize their full potentialthroughout the future of the series.
Dune: Prophecyis available to stream on Max in the U.S. New episodes stream every Sunday night.
Dune: Prophecy
Set in the universe of Frank Herbert’s Dune series, this sci-fi epic follows the political and spiritual struggles on the desert planet of Arrakis. As factions vie for control of the prized spice melange, a prophesied hero emerges, challenging the balance of power and the fate of the galaxy.
WATCH ON MAX
